
A guide to living in Edinburgh
Excellent
77.0
Very Good
18.0
Average
3.6
Disappointing
0.9
Very poor
0.5
Best places to live in Edinburgh
How is ranking calculated?HomeViews Top Rated Development ranking takes into account the Star Rating and the amount of verified reviews over the past 12 months.
Viewing 1-5 out of 20

The McEwan, EH3
By Moda Living
Award winner 2024
4.86
(176 reviews)
£1,281-£2,940 pcm
Studios, 1, 2, 3 beds
Ranked 1st out of 12 in Edinburgh

Kingsford Residence, EH7
By Kingsford Group
Award winner 2025
4.64
(109 reviews)
£1,350-£2,400 pcm
1, 2 beds
Ranked 2nd out of 12 in Edinburgh

PLATFORM_ in Edinburgh
By PLATFORM_
Award winner 2025
4.43
(23 reviews)
£1,370-£2,570 pcm
Studios, 1, 2, 3 beds
Ranked 3rd out of 12 in Edinburgh

The Strand @ Portobello, EH15
By Barratt Homes
4.43
(15 reviews)
Ranked 4th out of 12 in Edinburgh

Lloyds Living at South Fort Street, EH6
By Lloyds Living
4.40
(6 reviews)
Ranked 5th out of 12 in Edinburgh
Page 1 of 4
Featured developments in Edinburgh
Loading
Latest Reviews in Edinburgh
422 total reviews
Viewing 1-5 out of 422
Paul C (Tenant)
Verified Resident
The McEwan, EH3
Sept 2025
Posh student accommodation, noisy, would advise avoiding
Paul C (Tenant)
Verified Resident
The McEwan, EH3
Sept 2025
Please tell us about the good and bad aspects of living in your local area:
The external location of our apartment faces Drysdale Road - unless you like boy racers, avoid. Maintenance can be lacking, fire safety and security do not seem to be of concern to Moda.
How has the building management responded to any problems or issues you have raised:
Quite poorly in the majority of instances, and can be quite rude when prompted for a response.
Please share one thing (or more) which you wish you had known before you moved in:
That the property is a high percentage overseas students, not professionals as we were told when viewing.
A (Tenant)
Verified Resident
The McEwan, EH3
Sept 2025
Very expensive, good facilities, management is unreliable
A (Tenant)
Verified Resident
The McEwan, EH3
Sept 2025
Please tell us about the good and bad aspects of living in your local area:
Area is great. Everything you need is nearby. New Scotmid Coop is fantastic. Two bus stops very close to Moda
How has the building management responded to any problems or issues you have raised:
The elevator in 6 McEwan Walk took over a month to fix.
Please share one thing (or more) which you wish you had known before you moved in:
Flats get very warm during summer. Management generally avoids residents like the plague. Every simple question or request has to be done through the app or over email. It can get exhausting
Manager response
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We're really pleased to hear your positive comments about Moamen and Jawad — they are both valued members of our team and will be glad to know their efforts are appreciated. We're also glad you’re enjoying the location and local amenities like the new Scotmid Co-op and nearby transport links — we agree it's a great area to live in! We want to acknowledge the concerns you've raised, and we appreciate the opportunity to address them: 1. Warm Temperatures in the Flats: You're absolutely right — some apartments can get quite warm during the summer months, especially due to the energy-efficient design and large windows that maximise natural light. While this can be a benefit in winter, we understand it can be uncomfortable in warmer weather and this year's summer has been exceptional! 2. Communication Through the App or Email: We hear your feedback about the app-based communication. Our goal in using the app is to ensure consistency, accountability, and quicker response times for residents. That said, we understand that sometimes a quick chat in person is more efficient and you are always welcome to speak to someone at the front desk. 3. Elevator Downtime at 6 McEwan Walk: We sincerely apologise for the extended delay in repairing the lift. We completely understand how frustrating this must have been. It was fixed for a short while but then we realised it required a specific part which delayed the repair for longer than we’d hoped. 4. Additional Charges for Amenities: All amenities in the building are at no extra cost and are included within your rent. It is only if you wish to book these facilities privately or exclusively that there is a small fee upon booking. Thanks again for being part of the community and for your feedback which we take constructively.
Posted by
Leanne Reid, General Manager
Sept 2025
Abdullah S (Tenant)
The McEwan, EH3
Sept 2025
The design is good and modern
Abdullah S (Tenant)
The McEwan, EH3
Sept 2025
Please tell us about the good and bad aspects of living in your local area:
Moda located in very good location, Closed to COOP supermarket (1 min walk) and two main bus station (morrison and gilmore) and both of them just 1 min walk. Also, aurrounded by several shops and services such as berbers and fountain park. The good think also in Moda that you have your private car parking, bike parking, and bin store.
How has the building management responded to any problems or issues you have raised:
Directly, one you have any problem that need maintanence they directly come to solve. One tou have complain they help to solve.
Please share one thing (or more) which you wish you had known before you moved in:
I wish knew that Moda good as this level, to avoid spend one month finding for flat in Edinburgh. If i know they are good at this level i woll stay in their place directly.
Ruaridh G (Tenant)
Verified Resident
PLATFORM_ in Edinburgh
Aug 2025
Reviewer was offered an incentive for an honest review, regardless of rating
A fantastic development for anyone.
Ruaridh G (Tenant)
Verified Resident
PLATFORM_ in Edinburgh
Aug 2025
Please tell us about the good and bad aspects of living in your local area:
There is an excellent number of shops nearby, with a Tesco express and Lidl within walking distance. There are also two Michelin star restaurants nearby if you’re fancying a nice date or some fine dining with friends. The area itself is fantastic, very quiet with no disturbances from any nearby roads in the evening.
How has the building management responded to any problems or issues you have raised:
We are yet to have any issues with our flat and I have no doubt anything would be resolved very quickly!
Please share one thing (or more) which you wish you had known before you moved in:
I wouldn’t say there is anything I wasn’t clued up on before moving in. Our viewing was very informative and covered everything that was included with living here. We’re very happy!

Reviewer was offered an incentive for an honest review, regardless of rating
Xueqi (Tenant)
Verified Resident
The McEwan, EH3
Aug 2025
Helpful and reliable service
Xueqi (Tenant)
Verified Resident
The McEwan, EH3
Aug 2025
Please tell us about the good and bad aspects of living in your local area:
The local area is convenient and safe, with good transport links and shops within walking distance. Everything we’ve needed has been accessible and easy to find. Our experience living here has been positive so far.
How has the building management responded to any problems or issues you have raised:
So far, we haven’t encountered any major problems that required assistance. But based on our move-in experience, the team seems responsive and supportive, so we feel confident they’ll be helpful if anything comes up.
Please share one thing (or more) which you wish you had known before you moved in:
Nothing major so far — the move-in and settling-in process was well explained. Everything matched our expectations from the viewing and communication was clear throughout.
Manager response
Hi Xueqi, We're so happy to hear you've had such a positive experience — especially with Courtney’s support! It means a lot to know you felt welcomed and well taken care of. We're also glad you're enjoying the building and the community neighbourhood. Thanks for sharing your feedback — we’re always here if you need us! Team McEwan
Posted by
Leanne Reid, General Manager
Aug 2025
Page 1 of 85
These reviews are the subjective opinion of a HomeViews user and not of HomeViews